Re: NTFS driver (was: ReactOS GPL vs. proprietary drivers)

[Fabian Cenedese]

Hi

I don't know much about NTFS (only using it) and even less about
Linux-NTFS. But it was funny following this conversation.
> > Filesystem must be the rock solid data storage structure. You must
> > know the meaning of each byte (*) for such reliable and interoperable
> > filesystem.
>
> Exactly. Every needed byte is known.

Wow! Really?
> > (*) You do not need to know the journalling metadata as long as you do not
> >     support journalling and/or its recovery.
>
> One of the unknown issues is journaling :)

AHA! And not only "The unknown issue" but "One of the unknown issues".
Reminds me of Asterix: Whole Europe is part of the Roman Empire. Whole...?

Sorry, I couldn't resist, no offense :)

bye  Fabi

NTFS driver (was: ReactOS GPL vs. proprietary drivers)

[Szakacsits Szabolcs]

On Wed, 22 Oct 2003, Fabian Cenedese wrote:
> > > Filesystem must be the rock solid data storage structure. You must
> > > know the meaning of each byte (*) for such reliable and interoperable
> > > filesystem.
> >
> > Exactly. Every needed byte is known.
>
> Wow! Really?
> > > (*) You do not need to know the journalling metadata as long as you do not
> > >     support journalling and/or its recovery.
> >
> > One of the unknown issues is journaling :)
>
> AHA! And not only "The unknown issue" but "One of the unknown issues".

I expected this note. I extend my first sentence: every needed byte is
known to implement a posix read/write NTFS driver. 

Journaling is not posix, quota is not posix, enryption is not posix, etc.
NTFS has quite a lot of features. For basic read/write no need to
implement the extensions.
> Sorry, I couldn't resist, no offense :)

No, no. Please continue asking. Only stupid question is one not asked.

I think the root of problem that Linux open source NTFS development
"stopped" is because there are a lot of misbeliefs and people give up even
before they would try to accomplish it.

BTW, I hope the topic is not off-topic here. If it is then please let me
know and I stop answering. I always wondered how Wine users solve the
issue, running an application from an NTFS partition that needs read/write
access to NTFS ... I don't use Windows so I don't have much knowledge on
Wine but IMHO it's one of the most important open source projects.

	Szaka