Hi, What is the preferred number of spaces of indentation? In comdlg32/colordlg.c it is either one or three spaces and there are a few places where there is no indentation and where things are randomly indented or switches between amounts of indentation. What is the policy on when to change indentation and other things like turning something like this: if (condition) { ...some code... return 0; } return 1; into if (condition) return 1; ...some code... return 0; The page on style (http://www.winehq.org/site/docs/winedev-guide/style-notes) only contains very little on coding style. Another question, would it be OK to use smooth gradients in the colour dialog? It could be slow on older computer accessing each pixel individually although the code is only run on startup. Divan
Divan Burger schreef:
Hi,
What is the preferred number of spaces of indentation? In comdlg32/colordlg.c it is either one or three spaces and there are a few places where there is no indentation and where things are randomly indented or switches between amounts of indentation.
Some of wine's code is a mess with indentation, but alexandre won't commit indentation patches. This basically means that if there are multiple styles of indentations in the same file, you have to pick the one that is around the place where you put your function, although secretly when Alexandre isn't looking I sometimes pick the preferred '4 spaces' one.
What is the policy on when to change indentation and other things like turning something like this:
if (condition) { ...some code... return 0; } return 1;
into
if (condition) return 1;
...some code... return 0;
The page on style (http://www.winehq.org/site/docs/winedev-guide/style-notes) only contains very little on coding style.
Another question, would it be OK to use smooth gradients in the colour dialog? It could be slow on older computer accessing each pixel individually although the code is only run on startup.
Explicit patches that only do that are not accepted as far as I know, because it introduces bugs as you just skillfully demonstrated. ;-) However if you are rewriting the function you might end up doing that simplication in the process. Cheers, Maarten
On 10/01/2008, Maarten Lankhorst <maarten(a)codeweavers.com> wrote:
Divan Burger schreef:
Hi,
What is the preferred number of spaces of indentation? In comdlg32/colordlg.c it is either one or three spaces and there are a few places where there is no indentation and where things are randomly indented or switches between amounts of indentation.
Some of wine's code is a mess with indentation, but alexandre won't commit indentation patches. This basically means that if there are multiple styles of indentations in the same file, you have to pick the one that is around the place where you put your function, although secretly when Alexandre isn't looking I sometimes pick the preferred '4 spaces' one.
What is the policy on when to change indentation and other things like turning something like this:
if (condition) { ...some code... return 0; } return 1;
into
if (condition) return 1;
...some code... return 0;
The page on style (http://www.winehq.org/site/docs/winedev-guide/style-notes) only contains very little on coding style.
Another question, would it be OK to use smooth gradients in the colour dialog? It could be slow on older computer accessing each pixel individually although the code is only run on startup.
Explicit patches that only do that are not accepted as far as I know, because it introduces bugs as you just skillfully demonstrated. ;-)
However if you are rewriting the function you might end up doing that simplication in the process.
Cheers, Maarten
Oops, I was thinking about inversing the condition while I was writing it :) - if (condition) + if (!condition) What about if I change one line or add a line in a small function (approximately 15 lines). Will I be allowed to change the indentation or do that simplification above? The one line indentation makes it difficult to see the code structure sometimes and I also prefer the 4 spaces one.
participants (3)
-
Divan Burger -
Jeff Latimer -
Maarten Lankhorst