On Mon, Jan 4, 2010 at 9:06 AM, Wolfram Sang wrote:
>> task. There doesn't appear to be anything in this code that would be
>> patent encumbered, but the code itself certainly falls under
>> Hidenori's copyright which he has effectively revoked permission to
>> use.
>
> Strictly speaking, this is not possible. Although IANAL, this code is LGPL,
> so he can't revoke permission for this version of the code. He can ask to
> not use it, and this wish can be granted. You still should be allowed to
> pick it up. Next question is then, if a modified version will be picked up
> (still respecting the author's wish)? Or how much modifications are needed?
> Geez, such things are never trivial :(
>
Well, I put the LGPL header on the code. I thought I had that right
since the code was posted to wine-patches Anyhow, the legal side
isn't really relevant. The question is what Alexandre will accept as
far as it goes. The current code is certainly copyright by Hienori,
and since I couldn't contact him, I must assume he doesn't want any of
it in Wine. Thus my assumption is that I need to rewrite the entire
thing, if we want to obey his wishes (which I do). However, my hope
was that I could use the knowledge I gained from his implementation to
do it myself. As I'm already biased by that knowledge, if that won't
be allowed, then I can't do the work at all.