Oh, fine, start a flame war while I'm off travelling around Germany. <grin>
In my not very humble opinion, I think that any commercial support section of the WineHQ web site should be open to anyone that requests to be listed there, and that it should be in alphabetical order. However, I think the list should be fairly simple with a link to full details.
I do think that some reasonable pruning is fair; someone that is obviously trolling without any Wine credentials at all, or someone that falls off the map, for example, should get pruned. But it should be awfully hard to get kicked out, imo.
Now you can take my $0.02 and add EUR $1.48, and you have a cup of coffee (and you really will, because you don't have to factor in tax, and that's so nice) :-/
Cheers,
Jeremy