On 3/19/2010 10:57, Maarten Lankhorst wrote:
Hi Arjun,
On 19-03-10 05:25, Arjun Comar wrote:
GSoC 2010 Proposal: Buildbot Automated Testing System For those who aren't aware, http://buildbot.net/ provides an automated testing suite. I propose to set up a Buildbot system for Wine, using both a periodic scheduler, and a try scheduler. I also intend to create an easy configuration scheme that should keep maintenance fairly simple. In addition the test suite should be modular and easily extensible, ideally building on AppInstall and the existing test suite, as well as providing a means for new tests to be hooked in.
I'm a bit opposed, since there are 3 or 4 such projects already. So there has to be big advantage to your system if you want to introduce another.
I'm agreed with that. Testing is very important and should be done some way of course, but the priority is to extend unit testsuite I think. There's a lot of missed or incomplete parts and a lot of partially implemented things that aren't tested at all with unit tests. Running high level tests for an applicaiton is good but requires additional time spent to figure out what a regression about. Btw, I don't think AppInstall is widely used in Wine currently, correct me if I'm wrong.
If we really want to have a testing-only project it should be about unit-tests IMO, selected by some priority. Personally I prefer a work on some valuable module accompanied with complete tests for it.
Cheers, Maarten