This shows that although Windows is only matching family names up to LF_FACESIZE chars, and that it doesn't match against the preferred / typographic family names and styles, it still keeps the faces separate when the full names don't match. Wine incorrectly discard one of them.
Signed-off-by: Rémi Bernon rbernon@codeweavers.com ---
Just stumbled upon this while playing with fonts and fontconfig. Noto fonts have a lot of collisions because of this, as they have all sorts of density / weight / slant variations.
I don't have a fix yet, I'm not sure how to do it yet and I'd also like to take the opportunity to clean the corresponding gdi32 code a bit.
I thought it could be nice to use the typographic / preferred family and style names to enumerate and match them, as fontconfig does, but that's not what Windows is doing, sadly.
It could be a host integration and user experience improvement though, but it will require patching the font data before returning it, to pass the other tests.
dlls/gdi32/tests/font.c | 70 +++++++++++++++++++ dlls/gdi32/tests/resource.rc | 6 ++ dlls/gdi32/tests/wine_ttfnames.sfd | 85 ++++++++++++++++++++++++ dlls/gdi32/tests/wine_ttfnames.ttf | Bin 0 -> 2232 bytes dlls/gdi32/tests/wine_ttfnames_bold.sfd | 85 ++++++++++++++++++++++++ dlls/gdi32/tests/wine_ttfnames_bold.ttf | Bin 0 -> 2272 bytes 6 files changed, 246 insertions(+) create mode 100644 dlls/gdi32/tests/wine_ttfnames.sfd create mode 100644 dlls/gdi32/tests/wine_ttfnames.ttf create mode 100644 dlls/gdi32/tests/wine_ttfnames_bold.sfd create mode 100644 dlls/gdi32/tests/wine_ttfnames_bold.ttf
diff --git a/dlls/gdi32/tests/font.c b/dlls/gdi32/tests/font.c index ad894dfdcad..a452b362228 100644 --- a/dlls/gdi32/tests/font.c +++ b/dlls/gdi32/tests/font.c @@ -6940,6 +6940,75 @@ static void test_long_names(void) ReleaseDC(NULL, dc); }
+static void test_ttf_names(void) +{ + struct enum_fullname_data efnd; + char ttf_name[MAX_PATH], ttf_name_bold[MAX_PATH]; + LOGFONTA font = {0}; + HFONT handle_font; + int ret; + HDC dc; + + if (!write_ttf_file("wine_ttfnames.ttf", ttf_name)) + { + skip("Failed to create ttf file for testing\n"); + return; + } + + if (!write_ttf_file("wine_ttfnames_bold.ttf", ttf_name_bold)) + { + skip("Failed to create ttf file for testing\n"); + DeleteFileA(ttf_name); + return; + } + + ret = AddFontResourceExA(ttf_name, FR_PRIVATE, 0); + ok(ret, "AddFontResourceEx() failed\n"); + + ret = AddFontResourceExA(ttf_name_bold, FR_PRIVATE, 0); + ok(ret, "AddFontResourceEx() failed\n"); + + dc = GetDC(NULL); + + strcpy(font.lfFaceName, "Wine_TTF_Names_Long_Family1_Con"); + memset(&efnd, 0, sizeof(efnd)); + EnumFontFamiliesExA(dc, &font, enum_fullname_data_proc, (LPARAM)&efnd, 0); + ok(efnd.total == 0, "EnumFontFamiliesExA must not find font.\n"); + + /* Windows doesn't match with Typographic/Preferred Family tags */ + strcpy(font.lfFaceName, "Wine TTF Names Long Family1"); + memset(&efnd, 0, sizeof(efnd)); + EnumFontFamiliesExA(dc, &font, enum_fullname_data_proc, (LPARAM)&efnd, 0); + ok(efnd.total == 0, "EnumFontFamiliesExA must not find font.\n"); + + strcpy(font.lfFaceName, "Wine TTF Names Long Family1 Ext"); + memset(&efnd, 0, sizeof(efnd)); + EnumFontFamiliesExA(dc, &font, enum_fullname_data_proc, (LPARAM)&efnd, 0); + todo_wine + ok(efnd.total == 2, "EnumFontFamiliesExA found %d fonts, expected 2.\n", efnd.total); + + strcpy(font.lfFaceName, "Wine TTF Names Long Family1 Con"); + memset(&efnd, 0, sizeof(efnd)); + EnumFontFamiliesExA(dc, &font, enum_fullname_data_proc, (LPARAM)&efnd, 0); + todo_wine + ok(efnd.total == 2, "EnumFontFamiliesExA found %d fonts, expected 2.\n", efnd.total); + + handle_font = CreateFontIndirectA(&font); + ok(handle_font != NULL, "CreateFontIndirectA failed\n"); + DeleteObject(handle_font); + + ret = RemoveFontResourceExA(ttf_name_bold, FR_PRIVATE, 0); + ok(ret, "RemoveFontResourceEx() failed\n"); + + DeleteFileA(ttf_name_bold); + + ret = RemoveFontResourceExA(ttf_name, FR_PRIVATE, 0); + ok(ret, "RemoveFontResourceEx() failed\n"); + + DeleteFileA(ttf_name); + ReleaseDC(NULL, dc); +} + typedef struct { USHORT majorVersion; @@ -7351,6 +7420,7 @@ START_TEST(font) test_bitmap_font_glyph_index(); test_GetCharWidthI(); test_long_names(); + test_ttf_names(); test_char_width();
/* These tests should be last test until RemoveFontResource diff --git a/dlls/gdi32/tests/resource.rc b/dlls/gdi32/tests/resource.rc index 6dcbd42ab52..b5a6107a987 100644 --- a/dlls/gdi32/tests/resource.rc +++ b/dlls/gdi32/tests/resource.rc @@ -31,3 +31,9 @@ vertical.ttf RCDATA vertical.ttf
/* @makedep: wine_longname.ttf */ wine_longname.ttf RCDATA wine_longname.ttf + +/* @makedep: wine_ttfnames.ttf */ +wine_ttfnames.ttf RCDATA wine_ttfnames.ttf + +/* @makedep: wine_ttfnames_bold.ttf */ +wine_ttfnames_bold.ttf RCDATA wine_ttfnames_bold.ttf diff --git a/dlls/gdi32/tests/wine_ttfnames.sfd b/dlls/gdi32/tests/wine_ttfnames.sfd new file mode 100644 index 00000000000..566749d19a7 --- /dev/null +++ b/dlls/gdi32/tests/wine_ttfnames.sfd @@ -0,0 +1,85 @@ +SplineFontDB: 3.2 +FontName: Wine_TTF_Names_Long_Family1_Cond_Regular +FamilyName: Wine_TTF_Names_Long_Family1_Cond +Weight: Regular +Copyright: Copyright (c) 2020, Remi Bernon for CodeWeavers +UComments: "2017-11-17: Created with FontForge (http://fontforge.org)" +Version: 001.000 +ItalicAngle: 0 +UnderlinePosition: -102 +UnderlineWidth: 51 +Ascent: 819 +Descent: 205 +InvalidEm: 0 +LayerCount: 2 +Layer: 0 0 "Back" 1 +Layer: 1 0 "Fore" 0 +XUID: [1021 48 28337276 3092883] +OS2Version: 0 +OS2_WeightWidthSlopeOnly: 0 +OS2_UseTypoMetrics: 1 +CreationTime: 1510948643 +ModificationTime: 1598865292 +OS2TypoAscent: 0 +OS2TypoAOffset: 1 +OS2TypoDescent: 0 +OS2TypoDOffset: 1 +OS2TypoLinegap: 0 +OS2WinAscent: 0 +OS2WinAOffset: 1 +OS2WinDescent: 0 +OS2WinDOffset: 1 +HheadAscent: 0 +HheadAOffset: 1 +HheadDescent: 0 +HheadDOffset: 1 +OS2Vendor: 'PfEd' +MarkAttachClasses: 1 +DEI: 91125 +LangName: 1033 \ + "" \ + "Wine TTF Names Long Family1 Cond" \ + "Regular" \ + "" \ + "Wine TTF Names Long Family1 Extremely Long Full Name Condensed" \ + "" \ + "" \ + "" \ + "" \ + "" \ + "" \ + "" \ + "" \ + "" \ + "" \ + "" \ + "Wine TTF Names Long Family1" \ + "Condensed Regular" \ + +Encoding: ISO8859-1 +UnicodeInterp: none +NameList: AGL For New Fonts +DisplaySize: -48 +AntiAlias: 1 +FitToEm: 0 +WinInfo: 64 16 4 +BeginPrivate: 0 +EndPrivate +BeginChars: 256 1 + +StartChar: at +Encoding: 64 64 0 +Width: 1024 +VWidth: 0 +Flags: HW +LayerCount: 2 +Fore +SplineSet +259 332 m 29 + 468 664 l 29 + 514 332 l 29 + 259 332 l 29 +EndSplineSet +EndChar +EndChars +EndSplineFont diff --git a/dlls/gdi32/tests/wine_ttfnames.ttf b/dlls/gdi32/tests/wine_ttfnames.ttf new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2eb2ad1f95e7bb384abe41bcf68f64da320fefb9 GIT binary patch literal 2232 zcmdT`O>7%Q6#iy+?W8oKb_J*AFt|aaC_ft;MWu?6mDHvOQ>qXpJyhK+$@)jKcdfM( zVhN-kdqAQW1eFk%-YVsgs22{1142S57eGR&px#j_Js>zi%{SwT?exH(xG>i2eDBSB zZ{FX|8UnzRxCR^R#p22<Z-00-0!BX|cl_n^g(9BDQ>3pc`qkHFv#SaJ4M0>$uWvN` zCQc;plm3=-abvqJk+H4=_Bi*Qir;E>yR?ka9nzzfdZ+x^-oDHIDbmeq;BTJ%;nphg zkDT*WG7`s}1Z_=_o~Sn3J7W;flKz}@svd3lcpWR$m!zL)_&ZHpz>D0!Kw5@=BY3zw z(d9n<cXpdmtKGeac^+Nj{_{|=a(=ygx$B)+_yxxuGJtPhcz8>#-^I-_WB|*uZj&5^ zrMMi_(VQzidCSt4dV9U6qd87rM`;Sp%VS21I25@7#%A5L4#;_@w~G77iDTp<!KWF@ z&;GbnE^M+sdF1U}H-{_Q6YW!9L_*Lrdd{fz6wJBGyPo65+XYg}@;HSgSBF1E=UF5D z?0#w_A(Ddwgo;JY;c>*n;f(=S$N$fV?q&9k`kiGgmddfnvH~_nFtaBxyRbjv;6ZjT znfQKT-?j*`XDfC>vG+%k;<tr;rtm>FmwqPwTrPb&BT_#d99Xx1U(Hx$niIAtvE$xX zIToi#emNsbqV(vFO5RD_JFE$2v2L(n{k}5T!U(I~tA~yA;$4FsykuQAIDwS)k-<q! z^6l)&r*O)C%iuK9_Q$G29My+cIeS<jj~fPCyeWP**v55n++YW9in|6UAg%WdPU4dF zg~2Jz+XaKu$k;crga}P^5Tk|)s%SH+No?Q@*DPE;r-+vkpg|dlMWPrX^+Hl*t}$0- zXOlZ?oIbX-Obb|wnw_{-skY_h#u=G)v+k5!4jMJN7{p-|%5oITrD!u)3;gXMrotM} z2&pZ3!>pjl^&;&x$Y~Lm^r;o1qUP36r|)y5)%hVkz*;Q~<jP7>UgSm8lBFoD$fDn< z)jM-MDWrr7rGhQ0`g9%3L1nA%6BM<Hwq9dOC?~SKI9#shI1gR(jBDPIYhK?q?=jcB zzH8oNC-<!8=>9Ytd%B-)6r-?RjN(clvoo$dCsjxuL-KS;o(jn`A$ck!&xAnH+}!lp zX_e-GpUDDt*ab1eS6Ns2J(_owxH@@<bs6M7U<F##`HLzPcG_{!2<jbEoUM9Y7fY8X z2wMU5S7|1uv6`-lWDQ*AN!3FABn8+lH8zmz&ds>4OU{2?9^FZQC+&ly|5?-iS*!BR zF%3OPYVRc+>ReTOoiDypriXcBn6E_l4sxUf=h5Mi6qGux*@EAl!IyN5|1;FSvY|A4 Q+WL9-*GHcyjp6U~A6<%D%m4rY
literal 0 HcmV?d00001
diff --git a/dlls/gdi32/tests/wine_ttfnames_bold.sfd b/dlls/gdi32/tests/wine_ttfnames_bold.sfd new file mode 100644 index 00000000000..b3bf4ddfe90 --- /dev/null +++ b/dlls/gdi32/tests/wine_ttfnames_bold.sfd @@ -0,0 +1,85 @@ +SplineFontDB: 3.2 +FontName: Wine_TTF_Names_Long_Family1_Cond_Regular +FamilyName: Wine_TTF_Names_Long_Family1_Cond +Weight: Regular +Copyright: Copyright (c) 2020, Remi Bernon for CodeWeavers +UComments: "2017-11-17: Created with FontForge (http://fontforge.org)" +Version: 001.000 +ItalicAngle: 0 +UnderlinePosition: -102 +UnderlineWidth: 51 +Ascent: 819 +Descent: 205 +InvalidEm: 0 +LayerCount: 2 +Layer: 0 0 "Back" 1 +Layer: 1 0 "Fore" 0 +XUID: [1021 48 28337276 3092883] +OS2Version: 0 +OS2_WeightWidthSlopeOnly: 0 +OS2_UseTypoMetrics: 1 +CreationTime: 1510948643 +ModificationTime: 1598865292 +OS2TypoAscent: 0 +OS2TypoAOffset: 1 +OS2TypoDescent: 0 +OS2TypoDOffset: 1 +OS2TypoLinegap: 0 +OS2WinAscent: 0 +OS2WinAOffset: 1 +OS2WinDescent: 0 +OS2WinDOffset: 1 +HheadAscent: 0 +HheadAOffset: 1 +HheadDescent: 0 +HheadDOffset: 1 +OS2Vendor: 'PfEd' +MarkAttachClasses: 1 +DEI: 91125 +LangName: 1033 \ + "" \ + "Wine TTF Names Long Family1 CondBold" \ + "Regular" \ + "" \ + "Wine TTF Names Long Family1 Extremely Long Full Name Condensed Bold" \ + "" \ + "" \ + "" \ + "" \ + "" \ + "" \ + "" \ + "" \ + "" \ + "" \ + "" \ + "Wine TTF Names Long Family1" \ + "Condensed Bold Regular" \ + +Encoding: ISO8859-1 +UnicodeInterp: none +NameList: AGL For New Fonts +DisplaySize: -48 +AntiAlias: 1 +FitToEm: 0 +WinInfo: 64 16 4 +BeginPrivate: 0 +EndPrivate +BeginChars: 256 1 + +StartChar: at +Encoding: 64 64 0 +Width: 1024 +VWidth: 0 +Flags: HW +LayerCount: 2 +Fore +SplineSet +259 332 m 29 + 468 664 l 29 + 514 332 l 29 + 259 332 l 29 +EndSplineSet +EndChar +EndChars +EndSplineFont diff --git a/dlls/gdi32/tests/wine_ttfnames_bold.ttf b/dlls/gdi32/tests/wine_ttfnames_bold.ttf new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..919a5ea1310dd95904d882afb56b95aaf94dc9be GIT binary patch literal 2272 zcmdT`O>7%Q6#iy+?W7Qqq~hn$9ELQA6eZ5aMxj(bL`h?M2yGRj<WhCB#2eevde>Sz zA-)v}p&pRvjUpj_)C<ZjR_+`Ci9;?(2v9*iAc0i1g%g~h=9}@vPAY^7;=)+7?|X0F zn|Xh`V+a6`;R<Z56$;BQzxDp*80i0u(vg?WE)?(t9w+~?;xD{1m0d~suK}V=er>(# z*D#pAL;hRNx%I7v#He)@ut&J=l>B<F-R92d|B!rtDQs?hzT0xSK0&@#4*cTr+c#E- z?{dzRDM%f2Qrv5d{8+i#*dBm*hWr=ghr)Q>$E#STy(Irg)!(k+9A4!5Ir1{{tHC>& z*AuS4$K$`L#q~z}7G`*KgX_;h#mf1{&IcE~!Thgy)S&?Q`uSgODEeJe8^9=FS=J8O zeppJ%K^rZ()X}#ry;Enc^K`Vt>Dnkup=GnkXcdPl*TC4UcddO&-tJIw2RU(!Ql$7a zL;2Yq7dIA)xPn>C+PQWPm$WC^r>=^Gpl9@)QR^v~bCq{JM~t_5a%$%hDoIj@KgG|o zM*7+Q)M!Gadj|*=i<*bW5f2Y9^sqYqe?D|Cvv1VzG-I(;jzyLgu+fLiuE12j)#u<| zb~l~+KHst}LhRZ~oKoUeUt0X0Z!v}Uvbo`>ho8+2pBxoKKkx5bJAbT<S{vL>*kX|# zcU|RJoFMyUMl6cO`+F*R$8qbRCYZvS!2)BrX|RPpF=()jv*IIz9n4#i!6^(`Um2Xn zxc!2`LpWhyH+UFN+CQicaa12(=Img>H|(0h7QYngeO5X)u8OA&cJQY7$>0>E)iOAZ zi`I_@4`Ie$Gk6#i_8#UDqlP9DR8T@04R+-?)^Un73s=tx;w1#AQb%HrC_zNKh};Hg zLaO#Da%Gj%$ClQq1M_jMnN&*Uh8$l%C9`hUosdgGwIb(&B#I-s5hrp!E(WWCzZE1j zSmhZJttG!O%P5eZ=YCa6>cors)DlraODhQJ`!soVenb!ENJCPrR-!;IFBjx_evs;N zF^)>I;8!bQbDAec#kn}7mI|wcO`7-&14}_^GxP}xdb@_E2{n{MS$;%Z(leX~ZhFQ| z?~t2b*G=yMH@&W#-UBChcFi%ANjCXpH}xpQQKJwir9fsgt~?`ESRTXjbXcAW%QInl zDlE^0K-Jvz<mpM3@_(Pz1#Gh;5{9oTpmKe*1}bqOWd}9t)gfRt>a;0x^`UCAu-!<4 zY7jO}sW!t<mrfTei0VO6c1pIwT@&tI(It{BiOaO9(x{&VR@g`t_Ll2TXI$5%<iD<# zZmx%^LhtB**3W;}y?m)mum4q!J8$ZtmR3#COCMi8)8PlVNqY}DerE*d(V;FeL9LTo gEO<ZlZrlO>A5rV-MpBj?YyG_W+x<_J#o_z>Pvq`pzyJUM
literal 0 HcmV?d00001