On Thu, 22 Jan 2009, Paul TBBle Hampson wrote: [...]
If you don't need to manually install the third-party library on a stock installation of the application's officially supported Windows platform (e.g. Wow on Windows XP), then you should not need to manually install it in Wine. If you do, then that application cannot be rated platinum.
True, but not the point I'm talking about.
Strange. It seemed spot on to me and I have not seen anything that would make me think otherwise so far.
On a stock install of Windows XP, you'd have to go get the runtimes and install them, same as under a stock Wine prefix.
Are you sure? It's quite possible that some Windows component (IE 7, Messenger, a service pack, etc) installs these runtimes so that you would not see this issue on Windows XP (or Vista). If so the Warcraft 3 maintainer is correct and the application cannot be rated platinum.
So maybe rather than 'stock Windows installation' I should say an 'up to date Windows installation with no third party software'.