Duane Clark wrote:
Shachar Shemesh wrote:
Duane Clark wrote:
I do understand the aversion to scripts, but the wineinstall one is fairly mild. I've been using Wine for more than 3 years and have even done some development on it (I wish I had more time for that... sigh). Still, if I want to test with a clean install, I delete or move the old windows and .wine directories and just use wineinstall to create fresh versions. Because, well, it just works so well and is a lot easier than doing the configuration by hand.
My beef with wineinstall is that there is no way to isolate the configuration creation part from the install part. I think we should have a script that does only the configuration, fake root and registry creation. This way, the script can be bundled with the package and placed on the destination machine. such a script should be runnable without the sources dir (maybe by specifying the location of the template registry and such via command line, maybe created by ./configure).
This way, the order CAN be "./configure, make depend, make, make install, createconf" for normal install. Packagers can then do "./configure --templatedir=/usr/share/wine --prefix=/usr (etc) && make depend && make && TMPDIR=/tmp/winerpmroot make install", and run "createconf" from the "postinstall" section of the RPM sort of thing.
Opinions?
It sounds like you are looking for something useful for binary distributions. I think that wineinstall would normally only be used by someone who is downloading and installing their first source distribution.
Not entirely true either. I often find myself seeking to restore the config. Also, what about someone who downloaded the sources and installed wine system wide, and then wants to enable wine for a second user?
So I think wineinstall is appropriate for that.
For binary distributions, I think a GUI tool is more appropriate. And there exists a tool, winesetuptk, for that purpose. It is a long time since I tried that tool, but as I recall, it was fairly easy to use.
I disagree, even had I been looking for something useful for a binary distribution. A GUI tool would be the worst solution possible. winesetuptk is excellent for an end user trying to tweak his own configuration. Something that runs while rpm -i (or dpkg -i) cannot depend on GUI, for it would prevent it from running while installing the system.
Shachar
-
Shachar Shemesh