Wine users with a CD-ROM drive, please test

Hi,

this is my second call for participation, as only Jeff Zaroyko responded to the first one.

I wrote a testsuite for mcicda (play music from CD-ROM using the MCI).
Wine's testbot job #4330 at
https://testbot.winehq.org/JobDetails.pl?Key=4330
contains both a patch and binary of what I'd initially want to test about mcida.dll, 
solely lacking compatibility fixes that testing on YOUR machine will show to be necessary.

Please download the executable or compile the patch and execute it in MS-Windows:
mcicda_test.exe mcicda
mcicda.c:270: CD length 69:23:66
mcicda.c:325: track #1 length 989547ms
mcicda.c:375: track #1 length: 16m:29s:41frames
mcicda.c:410: last track length: 03m:28s:19frames
mcicda.c:418: last track position: 65m:57s:47frames
mcicda: 112 tests executed (0 marked as todo, 0 failures), 0 skipped.

BTW, I wrote patches to make all these tests succeed in Wine. Before
submission, I'd appreciate some more test data.

Thank you for your participation,
 Jörg Höhle

[Jeff Zaroyko]

On Fri, Aug 6, 2010 at 7:24 PM,   wrote:
> Hi,
>
> this is my second call for participation, as only Jeff Zaroyko responded to the first one.
>
> I wrote a testsuite for mcicda (play music from CD-ROM using the MCI).
> Wine's testbot job #4330 at
> https://testbot.winehq.org/JobDetails.pl?Key=4330
> contains both a patch and binary of what I'd initially want to test about mcida.dll,
> solely lacking compatibility fixes that testing on YOUR machine will show to be necessary.
>
> Please download the executable or compile the patch and execute it in MS-Windows:

Take #2.

I had a look at the CD I claimed was data+audio with a CDBurnerXP.
It's composed of two "sessions" one with audio tracks and the second
session is composed of only a data track.

C:\Users\jeffz\Desktop>mcicda_test.exe
mcicda.c:270: CD length 54:02:59
mcicda.c:325: track #1 length 76134ms
mcicda.c:392: Tests skipped: Got no mixed data+audio CD.
mcicda.c:410: last track length: 04m:37s:09frames
mcicda.c:418: last track position: 49m:27s:50frames
mcicda.c:425: Test failed: SEEK to 003B0436 position last + length:
MCIERR_HARDWARE
mcicda.c:436: Test failed: PLAY from 1 notify: MCIERR_HARDWARE
mcicda.c:439: Tests skipped: Cannot manage to play track 1.
mcicda: 64 tests executed (0 marked as todo, 2 failures), 2 skipped.

For comparison, I checked Jedi Knight: Dark Forces II CD1, it is shown
to have one session with a data track followed by audio tracks:

C:\Users\jeffz\Desktop>wintest.exe mcishell
mci.c:178: Type your commands to the MCI, end with Ctrl-Z/^D
open cdaudio alias c
mci.c:188: command: open cdaudio alias c
mci.c:193: Response: 1
status c type track 1
mci.c:188: command: status c type track 1
mci.c:193: Response: other
status c type track 2
mci.c:188: command: status c type track 2
mci.c:193: Response: audio

C:\Users\jeffz\Desktop>mcicda_test.exe
mcicda.c:270: CD length 69:42:40
mcicda.c:325: track #1 length 3022801ms
mcicda.c:375: track #1 length: 50m:22s:60frames
mcicda.c:410: last track length: 02m:10s:50frames
mcicda.c:418: last track position: 67m:33s:65frames
mcicda.c:425: Test failed: SEEK to 00282C45 position last + length:
MCIERR_HARDWARE
mcicda.c:436: Test failed: PLAY from 8 notify: MCIERR_HARDWARE
mcicda.c:439: Tests skipped: Cannot manage to play track 8.
mcicda: 74 tests executed (0 marked as todo, 2 failures), 1 skipped.

And for the same cd as used earlier with only audio:

C:\Users\jeffz\Desktop>mcicda_test.exe
mcicda.c:270: CD length 24:53:74
mcicda.c:325: track #1 length 252067ms
mcicda.c:392: Tests skipped: Got no mixed data+audio CD.
mcicda.c:410: last track length: 04m:54s:52frames
mcicda.c:418: last track position: 20m:01s:22frames
mcicda.c:425: Test failed: SEEK to 004A3718 position last + length:
MCIERR_HARDWARE
mcicda.c:436: Test failed: PLAY from 1 notify: MCIERR_HARDWARE
mcicda.c:439: Tests skipped: Cannot manage to play track 1.
mcicda: 64 tests executed (0 marked as todo, 2 failures), 2 skipped.

Blank CD:
C:\Users\jeffz\Desktop>mcicda_test.exe
mcicda.c:252: Test failed: info upc: MCIERR_HARDWARE
mcicda.c:255: Test failed: info identity: MCIERR_HARDWARE
mcicda.c:263: Test failed: STATUS number of tracks: MCIERR_HARDWARE
mcicda.c:266: Test failed: number of tracks=0
mcicda.c:269: Test failed: status length: MCIERR_HARDWARE
mcicda.c:274: Test failed: status position: MCIERR_HARDWARE
mcicda.c:279: Test failed: status position start: MCIERR_HARDWARE
mcicda.c:288: Test failed: play 02 to 01: MCIERR_HARDWARE
mcicda.c:295: Test failed: seek to noflag: MCIERR_HARDWARE
mcicda.c:298: Test failed: seek to start+end: MCIERR_HARDWARE
mcicda.c:302: Test failed: seek to start: MCIERR_HARDWARE
mcicda.c:313: Test failed: status position start (ms): MCIERR_HARDWAR
mcicda.c:323: Test failed: status length (ms): MCIERR_HARDWARE
mcicda.c:339: Test failed: STATUS type track 1: MCIERR_HARDWARE
mcicda.c:340: Test failed: unknown track type feedabad
mcicda.c:397: Tests skipped: Found no audio track.
mcicda: 53 tests executed (0 marked as todo, 15 failures), 1 skipped.

A DVD:

C:\Users\jeffz\Desktop>mcicda_test.exe
mcicda.c:229: Tests skipped: CD-ROM mode not ready
mcicda: 21 tests executed (0 marked as todo, 0 failures), 1 skipped

Jeff

Jeff Zaroyko wrote:
> Blank CD:
> mcicda.c:252: Test failed: info upc: MCIERR_HARDWARE
> mcicda.c:255: Test failed: info identity: MCIERR_HARDWARE
> mcicda.c:263: Test failed: STATUS number of tracks: MCIERR_HARDWARE
> mcicda.c:266: Test failed: number of tracks=0

I'll select an appropriate test based on Linux (and MacOS) results in Wine and add a skip.
> mcicda.c:425: Test failed: SEEK to 003B0436 position last + length:

MCIERR_HARDWARE
> mcicda.c:436: Test failed: PLAY from 1 notify: MCIERR_HARDWARE

I believe both errors have the same origin.

Here you really need to find out what command in the testsuite causes the
seek&play tests to fail with MCIERR_HARDWARE since you said you could
play music using MCI commands typed into the shell. Why can't the testsuite?
Luckily, almost all mciSendCommand can be converted to an equivalent string form.
Sadly, I have no clue what command may influence this -- perhaps MCI_RESUME?
> It's composed of two "sessions"

That'll make for an interesting testcase once we get rid of the above MCIERR_HARDWARE issue.

Thank you again,
  Jörg Höhle

Re : Wine users with a CD-ROM drive, please test

[paulo lesgaz]

Here is my result on a real Vista box using the CD: Police -Greatest hits

mcicda.c:270: CD length 67:55:74
mcicda.c:275: Test failed: status position initially 00:02:33
mcicda.c:280: Test failed: status position start 00:02:33
mcicda.c:314: Test failed: status position initially 2441ms
mcicda.c:325: track #1 length 192667ms
mcicda.c:392: Tests skipped: Got no mixed data+audio CD.
mcicda.c:410: last track length: 04m:12s:27frames
mcicda.c:418: last track position: 63m:46s:05frames
mcicda.c:425: Test failed: SEEK to 00203A43 position last + length: 
MCIERR_HARDWARE
mcicda.c:436: Test failed: PLAY from 1 notify: MCIERR_HARDWARE
mcicda.c:439: Tests skipped: Cannot manage to play track 1.
mcicda: 64 tests executed (0 marked as todo, 5 failures), 2 skipped.

David

________________________________
De : "[e-mail]" 
À : [e-mail]
Envoyé le : Ven 6 août 2010, 11h 24min 55s
Objet : Wine users with a CD-ROM drive, please test

Hi,

this is my second call for participation, as only Jeff Zaroyko responded to the 
first one.

I wrote a testsuite for mcicda (play music from CD-ROM using the MCI).
Wine's testbot job #4330 at
https://testbot.winehq.org/JobDetails.pl?Key=4330
contains both a patch and binary of what I'd initially want to test about 
mcida.dll,

solely lacking compatibility fixes that testing on YOUR machine will show to be 
necessary.

Please download the executable or compile the patch and execute it in 
MS-Windows:
mcicda_test.exe mcicda
mcicda.c:270: CD length 69:23:66
mcicda.c:325: track #1 length 989547ms
mcicda.c:375: track #1 length: 16m:29s:41frames
mcicda.c:410: last track length: 03m:28s:19frames
mcicda.c:418: last track position: 65m:57s:47frames
mcicda: 112 tests executed (0 marked as todo, 0 failures), 0 skipped.

BTW, I wrote patches to make all these tests succeed in Wine. Before
submission, I'd appreciate some more test data.

Thank you for your participation,
Jörg Höhle