Scrollbars, an application bug or a wine regression ? (#2314)

[Gabriele Giorgetti]

Hello, I've noticed a problem with scrollbars in the
latest Wine's release (20040615). With wine version
20040505 everything was just fine.

I've attacched a zip file with two screenshots
(pls. see wine BUG #2314 @ bugs.winehq.org )
the first one is the correct behavior of the app using
wine 20040505 the second one is wine 20040615 and the
app in its wrong behavior.

Trying to describe the problem:
The application show up with a bottom scrollbar and
a right scrollbar even if they are not needed. When
executing the very same application, with the very
same settings and size with wine 20040505 the scrollbars
are not there.

I hope you get it

Thanks.

NB: BUG #2314 at bugs.winehq.org

[George Marshall]

Gabriele Giorgetti wrote:

<snip>
> Trying to describe the problem:
> The application show up with a bottom scrollbar and
> a right scrollbar even if they are not needed. When
> executing the very same application, with the very
> same settings and size with wine 20040505 the scrollbars
> are not there.

I've also noticed that some unresizable windows are drawn
with the scrollbars.

[Nicolai Kuntze]

Am 29.06.2004 um 09:20 schrieb George Marshall:
> Gabriele Giorgetti wrote:
>
> <snip>
> > Trying to describe the problem:
> > The application show up with a bottom scrollbar and
> > a right scrollbar even if they are not needed. When
> > executing the very same application, with the very
> > same settings and size with wine 20040505 the scrollbars
> > are not there.
>
> I've also noticed that some unresizable windows are drawn
> with the scrollbars.

Me too. I submitted the bug as 2302 and added a demo application for 
download from a web server.

---- 
Diese Nachricht wurde auf Viren und andere gefaehrliche Inhalte sowie Spam untersucht.

[Nicolai Kuntze]

Is it possible that you got confused with the wine versions? I think 
you have permuted the names of your uploaded pictures .... Maybe I am 
wrong.

Am 25.06.2004 um 18:31 schrieb Gabriele Giorgetti:
> Hello, I've noticed a problem with scrollbars in the
> latest Wine's release (20040615). With wine version
> 20040505 everything was just fine.
>
> I've attacched a zip file with two screenshots
> (pls. see wine BUG #2314 @ bugs.winehq.org )
> the first one is the correct behavior of the app using
> wine 20040505 the second one is wine 20040615 and the
> app in its wrong behavior.
>
> Trying to describe the problem:
> The application show up with a bottom scrollbar and
> a right scrollbar even if they are not needed. When
> executing the very same application, with the very
> same settings and size with wine 20040505 the scrollbars
> are not there.
>
> I hope you get it
>
> Thanks.
>
> NB: BUG #2314 at bugs.winehq.org

---- 
Diese Nachricht wurde auf Viren und andere gefaehrliche Inhalte sowie Spam untersucht.

[George Marshall]

Nicolai Kuntze wrote:
> Is it possible that you got confused with the wine versions? I think you 
> have permuted the names of your uploaded pictures .... Maybe I am wrong.

Well no, with the Wine release of May the application had no
scrollbars (correctly) while with June release the scrollbars
are shown and are not working properly.

Regards.

[Dimitrie O. Paun]

On Wed, Jun 30, 2004 at 10:04:49AM +0200, George Marshall wrote:
> Well no, with the Wine release of May the application had no
> scrollbars (correctly) while with June release the scrollbars
> are shown and are not working properly.

Figuring out the exact patch that introduced the problem would
be most helpful:

http://winehq.org/site/docs/wine-devel/cvs-regression

[George Marshall]

Dimitrie O. Paun wrote:
> On Wed, Jun 30, 2004 at 10:04:49AM +0200, George Marshall wrote:
> > Well no, with the Wine release of May the application had no
> > scrollbars (correctly) while with June release the scrollbars
> > are shown and are not working properly.
>
> Figuring out the exact patch that introduced the problem would
> be most helpful:
>
> http://winehq.org/site/docs/wine-devel/cvs-regression

The patch that Dimitry Timoshkov posted in this topic fixes the 
(regression?) issue .

[George Marshall]

Gabriele Giorgetti wrote:
> Hello, I've noticed a problem with scrollbars in the
> latest Wine's release (20040615). With wine version
> 20040505 everything was just fine.
>
> I've attacched a zip file with two screenshots
> (pls. see wine BUG #2314 @ bugs.winehq.org )
> the first one is the correct behavior of the app using
> wine 20040505 the second one is wine 20040615 and the
> app in its wrong behavior.
>
> Trying to describe the problem:
> The application show up with a bottom scrollbar and
> a right scrollbar even if they are not needed. When
> executing the very same application, with the very
> same settings and size with wine 20040505 the scrollbars
> are not there.

Basically everything with the scrollbars worked fine
untill Wine 20040615.

Same correct (I guess) scrollbars behavior:
wine: 20031016,20031118,20031212,20040121,20040309,20040408,20040505

[Dmitry Timoshkov]

"George Marshall"  wrote:
> Basically everything with the scrollbars worked fine
> untill Wine 20040615.

Does reverting of the following patch help?

http://cvs.winehq.org/patch.py?id=12586

If no, you have to find an offending patch on your own.

[George Marshall]

Dmitry Timoshkov wrote:
> Does reverting of the following patch help?

Yes it does make the application work as it did before
the June Release.

Great !