bug irony - bug in firefox or xorg

[EA Durbin]

While browsing the bug database I discovered a bug, in which my x server 
crashes when i use the side horizontal scrollbar in firefox. I was browsing 
this attachment in firefox

http://bugs.winehq.org/attachment.cgi?id=2517&action=view

Can anyone replicate this bug?, I'm not sure whether to submit this bug to 
firefox or xorg. It crashes at the same point every time, when I try to use 
the horizontal scrollbar on this page. I opened firefox in the console and 
output the text to a file, upon logging back in to x i opened this file and 
had a message saying firefox lost the x session. I don't know if the bug 
resides in firefox or X?

[paul]

EA Durbin wrote:
> While browsing the bug database I discovered a bug, in which my x server 
> crashes when i use the side horizontal scrollbar in firefox. I was 
> browsing this attachment in firefox
>
> http://bugs.winehq.org/attachment.cgi?id=2517&action=view
>
> Can anyone replicate this bug?, I'm not sure whether to submit this bug 
> to firefox or xorg. It crashes at the same point every time, when I try 
> to use the horizontal scrollbar on this page. I opened firefox in the 
> console and output the text to a file, upon logging back in to x i 
> opened this file and had a message saying firefox lost the x session. I 
> don't know if the bug resides in firefox or X?

I have been told that an app can't crash X. So it is an X driver bug. I 
had frequent X crashes under wine gcad and other programs. my uinichrome 
built in hardware did not work with the xorg latest driver for it. I 
replaced with a Geforce fx 5200 and all is stable except ctrl alt += 
does not zoom with the nvidia drivers but opengl works but I only have 
1280x1024 resolution on a 17" LCD. Non nvidia drivers offer many 
resolutions but opengl does not function.

File an xorg bug.
Paul

[Molle Bestefich]

EA Durbin wrote:
> While browsing the bug database I discovered a bug, in which my x server
> crashes when i use the side horizontal scrollbar in firefox. I was browsing
> this attachment in firefox
>
> http://bugs.winehq.org/attachment.cgi?id=2517&action=view

Doesn't crash at all here using xorg7 and
Mozilla/5.0 (X11; U; Linux i686; en-US; rv:1.8b3) Gecko/20050712 Firefox/1.0+

[Nick Law]

Works ok for me, no crashes. ( Firefox 1.5.0.3, Xorg version 6.8.2, ATI 
graphics card 9550 driver V8.23.07 )
Nick

EA Durbin wrote:
> While browsing the bug database I discovered a bug, in which my x 
> server crashes when i use the side horizontal scrollbar in firefox. I 
> was browsing this attachment in firefox
>
> http://bugs.winehq.org/attachment.cgi?id=2517&action=view
>
> Can anyone replicate this bug?, I'm not sure whether to submit this 
> bug to firefox or xorg. It crashes at the same point every time, when 
> I try to use the horizontal scrollbar on this page. I opened firefox 
> in the console and output the text to a file, upon logging back in to 
> x i opened this file and had a message saying firefox lost the x 
> session. I don't know if the bug resides in firefox or X?